These Shallow Graves

These Shallow Graves is a young adult historical mystery by Jennifer Donnelly. First published in 2015, the book follows an aspiring reporter investigating her father’s death, and the terrifying secrets she uncovers. Receiving a positive reception following its release, critics praise it for its subtle feminist themes, and for how the main character defies expectations. Donnelly is the author of numerous books for young adults and early readers. In 2017, she collaborated with Disney to release Beauty and the Beast: Lost in a Book, the companion novel to the blockbuster movie remake.

Josephine Montfort, the daughter of one of the wealthiest men in New York, mingles in the most exclusive social circles. Her family sends her to a finishing school in Connecticut called Miss Sparkwell’s School for Young Ladies. Here, Josephine’s parents expect her to learn the skills she needs to make a good wife.

Although Josephine doesn’t care about getting married or being a dutiful wife, she knows she can’t escape her fate. Her parents want her to marry Abraham Aldrich, who comes from another well-connected and prosperous family. Although Abraham is handsome and charming, Josephine wants to choose her own future. More than anything, Josephine wants to be a writer.



Josephine already writes for the school magazine. The problem is, the topics she covers are mundane and trivial, such as knitting and baking. Like her father, she wants to be a very successful businessperson and entrepreneur. Her father doesn’t entertain her ideas because she’s a girl. Josephine, however, knows that women make great reporters—like her idol, Nellie Bly.

One day, Josephine is working on the school magazine when she receives unexpected—and unwelcome—visitors. Abraham and his sister want to see her. Unfailingly polite, Josephine has no choice but to see them. She assumes that Abraham is here to propose, but this couldn’t be further from the truth. He is here to tell her that her father is dead.

Josephine can’t believe what she is hearing. Abraham explains that her father died while cleaning his gun at home—a tragic accident. Abraham extends his sympathy to Josephine. Josephine, however, doesn’t believe that it was an accident. Anything but careless, her father’s a skilled sportsman, and he knows everything about gun handling. He wouldn’t be clumsy enough to clean a loaded gun.



It’s time for Josephine to become the investigative reporter she has always wanted to be. While Josephine’s mother mourns, and Abraham’s family despairs because the engagement is postponed, Josephine gets to work. She volunteers to handle some of her father’s bequests from his will to learn more about his business.

Josephine visits Arnold Stoatman to deliver a bequest. Arnold works at the Standard, a successful local newspaper owned by the Montforts. Josephine wanders around the office while she is waiting to see Arnold; no one bothers with her because she is a Montfort. Everyone is too afraid to speak to her.

Before she sees Arnold, she overhears a conversation between reporters. Eddie Gallagher claims that Mr. Montfort killed himself. He says the family paid the police to cover it up. Josephine hates to think that her father committed suicide, but this seems more likely than a tragic accident. She asks Eddie to take her home, giving her a chance to question him further.



Josephine wants proof that her father killed himself. Eddie explains that, while he doesn’t have proof, the bullet wound is consistent with a suicide shot. Josephine knows this isn’t enough to prove anything, but it gives her something to start with. She rummages around her father’s study when she gets home, looking for anything that might explain the situation.

Josephine finds paperwork connecting her father to mysterious people with their own business interests. This makes Josephine worry that her father got himself into trouble with dangerous people, and he didn’t have a way out of it. She asks her uncle about it, and he confirms it was probably a suicide. Everyone expects Josephine to stop digging, but she doesn’t.

Josephine’s uncle and Abraham’s family caution her against investigating matters. They want her to marry Abraham to secure her family’s future. A public scandal would make marriage impossible. Josephine, however, cares about her father too much to let it go. With Eddie’s help, Josephine discovers that he didn’t kill himself—he angered someone, and he angered them enough that they killed him.



Josephine soon discovers that her uncle killed her father. She is terrified and heartbroken. She also knows she can’t avoid the press finding out about this. Her mother is shocked and disappointed, but also relieved to know that her husband didn’t kill himself. Everything is exposed, Josephine’s uncle is arrested, and she assumes her engagement is off. Abraham, however, still wants to marry her if she will have him because he loves her.